| GC No.1056 of 2018GC No.1056 of 2018 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainant, Sandeep Kaur, filed a complaint …The complainant, Sandeep Kaur, filed a complaint against M/s ATS Estates Pvt. Ltd. for delayed possession of a flat in their project, ATS Golf Meadows S: Lifestyle. The authority accepted the complaint and directed the respondent to hand over possession of the apartment by 31.07.2019 and pay interest for the delay. |
["Delayed possessio…["Delayed possession", "Interest for delay"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that the respondent had delayed possession of the flat and sought relief for the same.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay was due to various reasons, including force majeure, and that they were not liable to pay interest for the delay.", "final_verdict": "The authority accepted the complaint and directed the respondent to hand over possession of the apartment by 31.07.2019 and pay interest for the delay.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Sandeep KaurSandeep Kaur |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| RERA GC No.1455 of …RERA GC No.1455 of 2019 |
PunjabPunjab |
Jyotsna Khanna filed a complaint against ATS Esta…Jyotsna Khanna filed a complaint against ATS Estates Pvt Ltd, but the case was dismissed in default as nobody appeared on behalf of the complainant. |
Default caseDefault case |
{"appellant_claim": "Not provided", "respondent_c…{"appellant_claim": "Not provided", "respondent_claim": "Not provided", "final_verdict": "The case was dismissed in default as nobody appeared on behalf of the complainant.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Jyotsna KhannaJyotsna Khanna |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.1449 of 2019 …GC No.1449 of 2019 and GC No.1490 of 2019 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainants alleged delay in handing over po…The complainants alleged delay in handing over possession of apartments by the respondent. The Authority held that the delay was established and directed the respondent to pay interest to the complainants for the period of delay. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Interest payment"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants alleged del…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants alleged delay in handing over possession of apartments by the respondent.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay was not established and that the complainants were not entitled to interest payment.", "final_verdict": "The Authority held that the delay was established and directed the respondent to pay interest to the complainants for the period of delay.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Mrs. Rita PanwarMrs. Rita Panwar |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.1584/2020GC No.1584/2020 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainant sought possession of a flat and i…The complainant sought possession of a flat and interest for delay, while the respondent argued that possession was offered in 2019 and the complaint was premature. The Authority held that there was substantial delay and ordered the respondent to pay interest. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Interest for delay"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that the respondent failed to deliver possession of the flat within the agreed-upon time frame and sought interest for the delay.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent argued that possession was offered in 2019 and the complaint was premature, and that the complainant was only entitled to compensation for delay as per the agreement.", "final_verdict": "The Authority held that there was substantial delay in delivering possession and ordered the respondent to pay interest as per the Act.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Shailesh NawalShailesh Nawal |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.1425/2019GC No.1425/2019 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complaints against ATS Estates Private Limited fo…Complaints against ATS Estates Private Limited for delay in possession of apartments and non-completion of amenities. Authority directed respondents to pay interest for delay and set off compensation paid by respondents. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Non-completion of amenities"] |
{"appellant_claim": "Delay in possession of apart…{"appellant_claim": "Delay in possession of apartments and non-completion of amenities.", "respondent_claim": "Partial completion certificates had been issued and physical possession was delivered before the coming into effect of the Act.", "final_verdict": "Respondents directed to pay interest for delay and set off compensation paid by respondents.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Mrs. Nidhi ChauhanMrs. Nidhi Chauhan |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.1828/2020GC No.1828/2020 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainant Kanishk Kapoor filed a complaint agai…Complainant Kanishk Kapoor filed a complaint against ATS Estates Private Limited for delay in possession of a flat. The Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Punjab, ordered the respondent to pay interest for the delay. |
Delay in possession…Delay in possession of flat |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that the respondent had delayed possession of the flat and sought interest for the delay.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay was due to various reasons, including non-deposit of timely payments by the allottees and force majeure conditions.", "final_verdict": "The Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Punjab, ordered the respondent to pay interest for the delay from 11.08.2016 till possession is handed over to the complainant after obtaining completion certificate.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Kanishk KapoorKanishk Kapoor |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.1684/2020GC No.1684/2020 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainant, Baljeet Kaur, filed a complaint …The complainant, Baljeet Kaur, filed a complaint against ATS Estates Private Limited for delay in delivery of possession of a flat. The authority directed the respondent to issue fresh offer of possession and pay interest for the delay. |
["Delay in delivery…["Delay in delivery of possession", "Interest for delay"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that the respondent delayed the delivery of possession of the flat and sought relief for the same.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay was due to various reasons, including obtaining partial completion certificate and that the complainant did not come forward to take possession.", "final_verdict": "The authority directed the respondent to issue fresh offer of possession within one month of the receipt of the order and pay interest for the delay from 28.02.2015 till 03.06.2019.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Baljeet KaurBaljeet Kaur |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.1685/2020GC No.1685/2020 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainant filed a complaint for lawful poss…The complainant filed a complaint for lawful possession and payment of interest on account of delay in delivery of possession of the unit in question. The Authority directed the respondent to issue fresh offer of possession within one month of the receipt of the order. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Interest payment"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that the respondent delayed the possession of the unit and sought payment of interest on account of the delay.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the possession was offered on 03.06.2019 and sought to terminate the allotment on 25.07.2020.", "final_verdict": "The Authority directed the respondent to issue fresh offer of possession within one month of the receipt of the order and pay interest from 28.02.2015 till 03.06.2019.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Jatinder KaurJatinder Kaur |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.0053/2021GC No.0053/2021 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainant sought delivery of possession of apar…Complainant sought delivery of possession of apartment and interest for delayed period. Authority granted interest for delayed period but not possession. |
["Delayed Possessio…["Delayed Possession", "Interest"] |
{"appellant_claim": "Complainant sought delivery …{"appellant_claim": "Complainant sought delivery of possession of apartment and interest for delayed period.", "respondent_claim": "Respondent claimed that project completion time was declared as 9 years and complaint was premature.", "final_verdict": "Authority granted interest for delayed period but not possession.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Navdeep VirkNavdeep Virk |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.1830/2020GC No.1830/2020 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complaint filed for delay in delivery of possessi…Complaint filed for delay in delivery of possession of a flat by the builder. The authority granted relief by directing the builder to pay interest for the delay. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Interest for delay"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The appellants claimed that …{"appellant_claim": "The appellants claimed that the builder had not delivered possession of the flat within the stipulated time and sought interest for the delay.", "respondent_claim": "The respondents claimed that the project was registered with the authority only in 2017 and the completion time was declared as nine years, making the complaint premature. They also claimed that the buyer's agreement was not in accordance with the prescribed rules and that the authority did not have jurisdiction to try the case.", "final_verdict": "The authority granted relief by directing the builder to pay interest for the delay in delivery of possession. The authority dismissed the respondents' legal objections and found that the complainants were eligible for interest under Section 18 of the Act.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Shashi MadanShashi Madan |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| RERA/AdC No.1074 of…RERA/AdC No.1074 of 2019 |
Not providedNot provided |
The case was withdrawn by the complainant with th…The case was withdrawn by the complainant with the liberty to file a fresh complaint before the appropriate forum. |
["Withdrawal of com…["Withdrawal of complaint"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant sought to wi…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant sought to withdraw the complaint with the liberty to file a fresh one before the appropriate forum.", "respondent_claim": "None", "final_verdict": "The complaint was dismissed as withdrawn with the liberty as prayed for.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Anuradha DuaAnuradha Dua |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC 0184 of 2021GC 0184 of 2021 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complaint against delay in delivery of possession…Complaint against delay in delivery of possession of unit booked in the project 'ATS Golf Meadows Lifestyle' developed by the respondent. The respondent is directed to pay interest at the rate of 9.30% per annum for the period of delay. |
["Delay in delivery…["Delay in delivery of possession", "Interest for the period of delay"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed tha…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed that the respondent had failed to deliver possession of the apartment and sought payment of interest for the period of delay.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay in delivery of possession was due to various reasons including change in government policies and the lockdown imposed due to Covid-19.", "final_verdict": "The respondent is directed to pay interest at the rate of 9.30% per annum for the period of delay.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Som Nath GandhiSom Nath Gandhi |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC 0177 of 2021GC 0177 of 2021 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complaint against delay in delivery of possession…Complaint against delay in delivery of possession of apartment by ATS Estates Pvt. Ltd. Complainants directed to pay interest for period of delay. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Interest payment"] |
{"appellant_claim": "Delay in delivery of possess…{"appellant_claim": "Delay in delivery of possession of apartment, interest for period of delay, and payment of outstanding rental amount.", "respondent_claim": "Not obligated to deliver possession before 30.08.2026, force majeure due to government policies and Covid-19.", "final_verdict": "Complainants directed to pay interest at 9.30% per annum from 01.07.2019 till valid offer of possession. Interest accrued till date of order to be paid within two months.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Brig. Gurdarshan Si…Brig. Gurdarshan Singh Grewal |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdC 132 of 2021 BF …AdC 132 of 2021 BF TR |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainants sought refund for delayed possession…Complainants sought refund for delayed possession of apartments. Authority directed refund with interest. |
["Delayed possessio…["Delayed possession", "Refund"] |
{"appellant_claim": "Refund for delayed possessio…{"appellant_claim": "Refund for delayed possession of apartments", "respondent_claim": "Possession was not due until later, compensation was paid as per agreement", "final_verdict": "Refund with interest to be paid within stipulated time", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Bhavna CuccriaBhavna Cuccria |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC 0310 of 2021GC 0310 of 2021 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complaint for delay in delivery of possession of …Complaint for delay in delivery of possession of apartment. Complainants entitled to payment of interest. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Interest payment"] |
{"appellant_claim": "Delay in delivery of possess…{"appellant_claim": "Delay in delivery of possession of apartment. Payment of interest for the period of delay.", "respondent_claim": "Compensation for delay paid as per agreement. Validity of project registration not yet reached.", "final_verdict": "Complainants entitled to payment of interest at prescribed rate from 1.7.2016 till valid offer of possession.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Rajesh Kumar Chande…Rajesh Kumar Chandel s/o Shri Kartar Singh Chandel |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC 1213 of 2019GC 1213 of 2019 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainants sought refund of deposited amount wi…Complainants sought refund of deposited amount with interest for delay in delivery of possession of apartment and compensation for harassment. Adjudicating Officer allowed refund with interest and damages. This complaint was remanded for fresh decision and after hearing arguments, the complaint was accepted and the respondent directed to refund the amount with interest. |
["Refund of deposit…["Refund of deposited amount", "Delay in delivery of possession"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed ref…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed refund of the amount deposited by them along with interest thereon on account of delay in delivery of possession of the apartment; and compensation for the harassment and mental agony caused to them.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the complainants had not followed the proper procedure for seeking refund and that the delay in delivery of possession was due to unforeseen circumstances.", "final_verdict": "The complaint was accepted and the respondent was directed to refund the amount of Rs. 47,52,617/- with interest at the prescribed rate (today's SBI highest MCLR rate plus 2%) from the date of deposit till the date of actual refund.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Anita Juliet SinghAnita Juliet Singh |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.435 of 2021GC No.435 of 2021 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainants sought interest for the delay in…The complainants sought interest for the delay in delivery of possession of an apartment. The respondent was directed to pay interest at the prescribed rate from 1.1.2019 till a valid offer of possession is made. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Interest payment"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed int…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed interest for the delay in delivery of possession of an apartment.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the agreement was not governed by the RERA Act and that the possession date was not relevant.", "final_verdict": "The respondent was directed to pay interest at the prescribed rate from 1.1.2019 till a valid offer of possession is made.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Ranjana FauzdarRanjana Fauzdar |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC 0038 of 2022GC 0038 of 2022 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainant, Rajinder Kumar Gandhi, filed a c…The complainant, Rajinder Kumar Gandhi, filed a complaint against ATS Estates Pvt. Ltd for delay in handing over possession of a flat. The Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Punjab, allowed the complaint and directed the respondent to pay interest to the complainant. |
Delay in handing ov…Delay in handing over possession |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that the respondent had delayed handing over possession of the flat and sought interest for the period of delay.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay was due to various reasons, including force majeure.", "final_verdict": "The Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Punjab, allowed the complaint and directed the respondent to pay interest to the complainant at the rate of 10.75% per annum from 01.02.2016 till the actual delivery of possession.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Rajinder Kumar Gand…Rajinder Kumar Gandhi |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdC no.0037 of 2022AdC no.0037 of 2022 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainant, Rajinder Kumar Gandhi, filed a c…The complainant, Rajinder Kumar Gandhi, filed a complaint against ATS Estates Pvt. Ltd. for delay in handing over possession of a flat. The Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Punjab, allowed the complaint and directed the respondent to pay interest to the complainant for the period of delay. |
Delay in handing ov…Delay in handing over possession |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that the respondent had delayed handing over possession of the flat and sought interest for the period of delay.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay was due to various reasons, including force majeure, and sought to dismiss the complaint.", "final_verdict": "The Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Punjab, allowed the complaint and directed the respondent to pay interest to the complainant for the period of delay.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Rajinder Kumar Gand…Rajinder Kumar Gandhi |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC No.0211 of 2022GC No.0211 of 2022 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainants sought refund along with interes…The complainants sought refund along with interest for the period of delay in handing over possession of the apartment in the project 'ATS Golf Meadows Lifestyle 2'. The respondent was directed to refund Rs.19,73,125/- along with interest at the rate of 10.85% per annum. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Refund with interest"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed ref…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed refund along with interest for the period of delay in handing over possession of the apartment in the project 'ATS Golf Meadows Lifestyle 2'.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the complainants had not approached the Authority with clean hands and that the complaint was liable to be dismissed.", "final_verdict": "The respondent was directed to refund Rs.19,73,125/- along with interest at the rate of 10.85% per annum.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Chand RaniChand Rani |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| TR AO/52/2019TR AO/52/2019 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainant, Sundar Krishnan, filed a complai…The complainant, Sundar Krishnan, filed a complaint against ATS Estates Private Limited for violation of Section 18 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016. The respondent was directed to return the amount of Rs.25,25,000/- along with simple interest at the State Bank of India highest marginal cost of lending rate plus 2% from the respective dates of payments by the complainant till realization. |
["Violation of Sect…["Violation of Section 18 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that the respondent failed to deliver possession of the plot within the stipulated time and sought refund of Rs.25,25,000/- with interest and compensation.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the project was registered with RERA Authority in September, 2017 and a period of nine years was granted for completion of the project, which was to expiry in August, 2026, and therefore, the present complaint was pre-mature.", "final_verdict": "The respondent was directed to return the amount of Rs.25,25,000/- along with simple interest at the State Bank of India highest marginal cost of lending rate plus 2% from the respective dates of payments by the complainant till realization.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Sundar KrishnanSundar Krishnan |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| TR AO/05/2019TR AO/05/2019 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainant, Raghunandan Sathyanarayan Rao, f…The complainant, Raghunandan Sathyanarayan Rao, filed a complaint against ATS Estates Private Limited for violation of Section 18 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016. The Adjudicating Officer ordered the respondent to refund the amount paid by the complainant with interest and compensation for mental agony and litigation expenses. |
["Violation of Sect…["Violation of Section 18 of RERA Act"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed refu…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed refund of the amount paid by him to the respondent with interest and compensation for delay in delivery of possession.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the project was registered with RERA Authority in September 2017 and a period of five years was granted for completion of the project.", "final_verdict": "The Adjudicating Officer ordered the respondent to refund the amount paid by the complainant with interest and compensation for mental agony and litigation expenses.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Raghunandan Sathyan…Raghunandan Sathyanarayan Rao |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| TR AO/06/2019TR AO/06/2019 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainant sought refund and interest for delay …Complainant sought refund and interest for delay in possession of plot. Adjudicating Officer ordered refund with interest and compensation for mental agony and litigation expenses. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Refund with interest"] |
{"appellant_claim": "Complainant claimed refund a…{"appellant_claim": "Complainant claimed refund and interest for delay in possession of plot measuring 350 square yards.", "respondent_claim": "Respondent claimed that possession was offered and project completion period was five years from registration date.", "final_verdict": "Adjudicating Officer ordered refund of Rs.26,21,250 with interest at State Bank of India highest marginal cost of lending rate plus 2% and compensation of Rs.1,25,000 for mental agony and litigation expenses.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Sujatha RaghunandanSujatha Raghunandan |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| ADC 1281/2019ADC 1281/2019 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainants, Anupam Garg and Umesh Garg, fil…The complainants, Anupam Garg and Umesh Garg, filed a complaint against ATS Estates Private Limited for violation of Section 18 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016. The complainants sought refund and interest for the delay in handing over possession of their apartment. |
Delay in possession…Delay in possession of apartment |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed tha…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed that the respondent failed to deliver possession of their apartment within the stipulated period and sought refund and interest.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay was due to unforeseen circumstances and that the complainants were not entitled to refund and interest.", "final_verdict": "The adjudicating officer directed the respondent to pay the complainants Rs.84,80,664/- along with simple interest at the State Bank of India highest marginal cost of lending rate as on this date plus 2% from the respective dates of payments by the complainants till realization.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Umesh GargUmesh Garg |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdcNo12072019AdcNo12072019 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainant, Nand Lal, withdrew his complaint…The complainant, Nand Lal, withdrew his complaint with permission to file a fresh complaint in Form-M seeking relief of possession of the flat. The case was allowed to withdraw and the file was consigned to the record room. |
["Withdrawal of com…["Withdrawal of complaint"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant claimed that he wanted to seek the relief of possession of the flat in question.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent did not make any claims in this case.", "final_verdict": "The case was allowed to withdraw with permission to file a fresh complaint in Form-M.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Nand LalNand Lal |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdC No. 1243/2019AdC No. 1243/2019 |
Not providedNot provided |
The complainant withdrew the present complaint an…The complainant withdrew the present complaint and sought permission to file a fresh complaint on the same cause of action. The present complaint was allowed to be withdrawn and dismissed. |
["Withdrawal of com…["Withdrawal of complaint", "Permission to file fresh complaint"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant sought relie…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant sought relief of refund, interest, and compensation, but later withdrew the complaint and sought permission to file a fresh complaint for possession.", "respondent_claim": "Not provided", "final_verdict": "The present complaint was dismissed, and permission was granted to file a fresh complaint on the same cause of action.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Anr.Anr. |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdcNo1393 of 2019URAdcNo1393 of 2019UR |
Not providedNot provided |
The complainant withdrew the present complaint wi…The complainant withdrew the present complaint with permission to file a fresh complaint on the same cause of action after giving further particulars of the case before the appropriate forum. |
["Withdrawal of com…["Withdrawal of complaint"] |
{"appellant_claim": "Not provided", "respondent_c…{"appellant_claim": "Not provided", "respondent_claim": "Not provided", "final_verdict": "The present complaint is ordered to be dismissed as withdrawn with permission to the complainant to file a fresh complaint on the same cause of action after furnishing further particulars, before the appropriate forum.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Harjinder KaurHarjinder Kaur |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdC 0132 of 2021AdC 0132 of 2021 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainants sought refund and compensation for d…Complainants sought refund and compensation for delay in possession of apartments in the 'ATS Golf Meadows Lifestyle' project. The Adjudicating Officer allowed partial compensation for delay, unfair advantage, mental agony, and harassment. |
Delay in possession…Delay in possession of apartments |
{"appellant_claim": "Refund and compensation for …{"appellant_claim": "Refund and compensation for delay in possession of apartments", "respondent_claim": "Delay in completion of project due to unforeseen circumstances", "final_verdict": "Partial compensation awarded for delay, unfair advantage, mental agony, and harassment", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Bhavna CuccriaBhavna Cuccria |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| APPEAL NO.212 OF 20…APPEAL NO.212 OF 2022 |
PunjabPunjab |
The appellant, Jyotsna Khanna, filed an appeal ag…The appellant, Jyotsna Khanna, filed an appeal against ATS Estates Private Limited and Dynamic Colonisers Pvt. Ltd. The appeal was disposed of by the Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, Punjab, with the direction that the interest shall flow to the appellant w.e.f. 13.10.2018 instead of 13.04.2019. |
["Interest payment …["Interest payment date"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The appellant claimed that t…{"appellant_claim": "The appellant claimed that the interest should be paid from 13.04.2019.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the interest should be paid from 13.10.2018.", "final_verdict": "The Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, Punjab, directed that the interest shall flow to the appellant w.e.f. 13.10.2018 instead of 13.04.2019.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Jyotsna KhannaJyotsna Khanna |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| APPEAL NO. 132 OF 2…APPEAL NO. 132 OF 2022 |
PunjabPunjab |
The appellant, Bikram Jit Singh, withdrew his app…The appellant, Bikram Jit Singh, withdrew his appeal against ATS Estates Private Limited and ATS Infrastructure Limited. The appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. |
["Withdrawal of app…["Withdrawal of appeal"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The appellant claimed that h…{"appellant_claim": "The appellant claimed that he wished to withdraw his appeal.", "respondent_claim": "The respondents did not make any claims.", "final_verdict": "The appeal was dismissed as withdrawn.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Bikram Jit SinghBikram Jit Singh |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdC No.0236 of 2022AdC No.0236 of 2022 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainants, Saurabh Sehgal and his wife Yam…The complainants, Saurabh Sehgal and his wife Yamini Gambhir, filed a complaint against ATS Estates Pvt Ltd and HDFC Bank Ltd for delay in possession of their flat in the project 'ATS Golf Meadows Lifestyle'. The Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) directed ATS Estates to pay interest at the rate of 10.85% per annum for the period of delay. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Interest payment"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed tha…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed that they had paid Rs. 45,76,000/- to ATS Estates and had not received possession of their flat despite several requests.", "respondent_claim": "ATS Estates claimed that the delay in possession was due to various reasons, including force majeure, and that the complainants had not approached them with clean hands.", "final_verdict": "The RERA directed ATS Estates to pay interest at the rate of 10.85% per annum for the period of delay.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Yamini GambhirYamini Gambhir |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| GC 0216/2022GC 0216/2022 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complaint filed by Sh. Sumit Garg against Ms. ATS…Complaint filed by Sh. Sumit Garg against Ms. ATS Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. for the registered project ATS Golf Meadows-V. The complaint was dismissed as withdrawn. |
["Withdrawn complai…["Withdrawn complaint"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainant filed a comp…{"appellant_claim": "The complainant filed a complaint against the respondents for the registered project ATS Golf Meadows-V.", "respondent_claim": "The respondents did not file any claim.", "final_verdict": "The complaint was dismissed as withdrawn.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Sh. Sumit GargSh. Sumit Garg |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| 1332 of 20191332 of 2019 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainants Anil Chopra and Ashima Chopra filed …Complainants Anil Chopra and Ashima Chopra filed a complaint against M/s ATS Estates Pvt. Ltd. for delay in handing over possession of their apartment in the project 'ATS Golf Meadow Lifestyle'. The Authority directed the respondents to pay interest at the rate of 9.30% per annum from 01.09.2016 till possession is handed over. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Interest payment"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed tha…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed that the respondents had delayed handing over possession of their apartment and sought direction to the respondents to hand over early possession and payment of interest for this delay.", "respondent_claim": "The respondents did not file a reply despite numerous opportunities granted to them.", "final_verdict": "The Authority directed the respondents to pay interest at the rate of 9.30% per annum from 01.09.2016 till possession is handed over.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Ashima ChopraAshima Chopra |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdC 1647 of 2020AdC 1647 of 2020 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainants sought refund of money deposited for…Complainants sought refund of money deposited for a delayed real estate project. The authority directed the respondent to refund the amount with interest. |
["Real estate proje…["Real estate project delay", "Refund of deposit"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed tha…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed that the respondent had delayed the delivery of possession of the apartment and sought refund of the money deposited with interest.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay was due to force majeure and that the complainants had not paid their instalments on time.", "final_verdict": "The authority directed the respondent to refund the amount deposited by the complainants with interest at the rate of 9.30% p.a.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Prerna Hoogan TejaPrerna Hoogan Teja |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdC0097 of 2021 BF …AdC0097 of 2021 BF TR |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainants sought refund for delayed possession…Complainants sought refund for delayed possession of a flat. Authority directed refund with interest, after considering various contentions from respondents. |
["Refund for delaye…["Refund for delayed possession"] |
{"appellant_claim": "Refund of amount deposited w…{"appellant_claim": "Refund of amount deposited with interest for delayed possession of flat.", "respondent_claim": "Various contentions including arbitration clause, validity of project registration, and compensation for delay.", "final_verdict": "Refund with interest directed, with first charge on refund for loan liability.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Shashi GoyalShashi Goyal |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| ADC 1647/2020ADC 1647/2020 |
PunjabPunjab |
The complainants filed a complaint against the re…The complainants filed a complaint against the respondent for delay in delivery of possession of a flat and sought compensation for mental agony and litigation expenses. The adjudicating officer partly allowed the complaint and directed the respondent to pay compensation to the complainants. |
["Delay in delivery…["Delay in delivery of possession", "Compensation for mental agony"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed tha…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed that the respondent had delayed delivery of possession of the flat and sought compensation for mental agony and litigation expenses.", "respondent_claim": "The respondent claimed that the delay was due to force majeure and that the complainants had not paid their installments as per schedule.", "final_verdict": "The adjudicating officer partly allowed the complaint and directed the respondent to pay compensation to the complainants.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Ms. Prerna Hoogan T…Ms. Prerna Hoogan Teja |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdC0097 of 2021AdC0097 of 2021 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainants sought refund and compensation for d…Complainants sought refund and compensation for delay in possession of a residential apartment. The Adjudicating Officer partly allowed the complaint, directing the respondents to pay compensation for delay and litigation expenses. |
["Delay in possessi…["Delay in possession", "Compensation"] |
{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed ref…{"appellant_claim": "The complainants claimed refund and compensation for delay in possession of the residential apartment.", "respondent_claim": "The respondents claimed that the complainants had not made the requisite payments as per the payment schedule and that the delay in completion of the project was due to lockdown as a result of Covid-19.", "final_verdict": "The Adjudicating Officer partly allowed the complaint, directing the respondents to pay compensation for delay and litigation expenses.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Shashi GoyalShashi Goyal |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
| AdC no.0222 of 2021AdC no.0222 of 2021 |
PunjabPunjab |
Complainant Neeraj Dimri sought refund of Rs. 50,…Complainant Neeraj Dimri sought refund of Rs. 50,60,000 with interest for delay in possession of flat by ATS Estates Pvt. Ltd. Authority directed refund with interest at 10.75% p.a. |
Delay in possession…Delay in possession of flat |
{"appellant_claim": "Complainant sought refund of…{"appellant_claim": "Complainant sought refund of Rs. 50,60,000 with interest for delay in possession of flat by respondent.", "respondent_claim": "Respondent claimed that delay was due to various reasons including force majeure and that complainant had not approached with clean hands.", "final_verdict": "Authority directed respondent to refund amount with interest at 10.75% p.a.", "in_favor_of_respondent": "no"} |
Neeraj DimriNeeraj Dimri |
ATS Estates Private…ATS Estates Private Limited |
Link |
